Follow

Ariff Alfian Rosli and his rights (or no right) to be gay

I have been receiving a lot of emails about this article (of course, there are lots more emails about the RM15 million marriage). Just a reminder, you don't have to email me about your feeling - just post whatever you feel on the comment box and I promise you, with the moon as my witness, I will not censor anything.

First, who is Ariff Alfian Rosli? Many claimed he was from MCKK and some went as far as calling the school MC Gay Gay. Just to get it right, MCKK does not produce gays but they produce a number of great politicians and great businessmen. Of course, it is just incidental that one of the high profile sodomy cases happening right now involves a former MCKK old boy.

Ariff Alfian, I believe, is a former head prefect (or like they call them now "ketua umum") of Sekolah Menengah Seksyen 5, Wangsa Maju. He is also one of the brightest boys ever produced by the school. I was told, PETRONAS send only a few people, probably less than 10, to do medicine overseas. You need to score straight As in all subjects to win such scholarship so probably Ariff Alfian scored straight As in all subjects. In other words, unlike many of us he is not an ordinary guy, at least academically.

Gay is a word (a noun or an adjective) that refers to a homosexual person. The term was originally used to refer to feelings of being "carefree", "happy", or "bright and showy"; it had also come to acquire some connotations of "immorality" as early as 1637. The term's use as a reference to homosexuality may date as early as the late 19th century, but its use gradually increased in the 20th century. (The reference is from Wikipedia)

Being gay used to be looked down in almost every part of the world. In fact, almost all countries have laws that prohibit homosexual relationship until a few years ago. A few years ago some countries begun to dismantle homosexuality laws and some including some states in the US of A and most countries under EU legalized gay marriage. And probably Ireland is one of them.

If you look closely, most of the countries that legalize gay marriages are countries that strongly believe in individual rights over collective rights. If you read UK newspapers, you wonder whether criminals have better rights than victims. There are cases where victims who tried to protect their properties or their loved ones were instead punished. That is just a crude example of individual right.

Homosexuality is not only abhored by common people but universally by almost all religions. So the legalization of gay relationship goes against the principle of almost all religions in this world. If you are gay, we can safely conclude, you are not religious. But courts in America and Europe strongly lean towards individual rights over collective rights so you have gays pastors, gay preachers and so and so in such countries.

If there is anyone to blame for this fiasco, it is the religious bodies. Schools now have more religious lessons than 20 or 30 years ago. We are being bombarded with religion daily through radio, televison and billboards. But they are more interested in form and not substance. True, we have a number of "murtads" but most are those who converted to Islam through marriage and once the marriage crumbles, they apply to court to renounce Islam. It happens because we do not teach them the good things about Islam but we are more interested about numbers. We are interested about how many Christians convert to Islam and not how many many have now become good Muslims. We are more interested about how many get caned for drinking beer? We are more interested about how many foods contain DNA traces of pig? I remember clearly, the case of body-snatching at a local hospital not so long ago. It was a tug-of-war between a religious body and a Hindu family. At that time, I was a frequent visitor to the hospital since my wife had been warded for some health reasons. There were a lot of unclaimed bodies at KLH and most were Muslims. No religious body was interested to help them. And they died unknown except there were some humble Muslims at the hospital who went round collecting donations to ensure these Muslims were propely buried according to Muslim rites. Yes sir, no religious body was interested in these dead drug addicts or misers since their deaths would go unannounced in newspapers or TV. They were more interested in high-profile cases even if the guy's Islamic status was doubtful.

The question of why we still have cases like Ariff Alfian Rosli is best answered by the relevant religious bodies. To say that a highly bright guy such as Ariff fall down to temptations is totally unjustifiable. If a highly intelligent guy could succumb to temptations then God help most of us.

The case of Ariff Alfian Rosli is not an isolated case. Personally, I know two other cases of old boys (those from STAR and not MCKK) cohabiting with Mat Saleh in homosexual relationship. One in USA and another in Australia. So to call MCKK MC Gay Gay is not the right thing to do.

Since it is almost impossible for Malaysian authorities (including the religious minister who said he would investigate this matter) to interfere in this case, it is best we let the case rest. The best government could do is to get PETRONAS off his parents' back.

PHOTOS HERE

Comments  

 
Sotongkering
#11 Sotongkering December 2011
remember Allah...and seek his forgiveness..
Quote
 
 
Soto
#10 Soto December 2011
we dont have the right to judge him...but for sure he had some hidden agenda..wearing baju mealyu..what the hell ....smart or intelligence does not make a guy.....wise
Quote
 
 
MNor
#9 MNor December 2011
Being Gay does not make you a lesser person. In fact there are gays every where even in some islamic countries that I have travelled to, and that being in the Middle East. In Malaysia, it seems the Islamic councils are being more Islamic than where Islam orginated from but the level of corruption in Malaysia, does not seem to decrease though it is seriously "haram" to accept or offer bribes.. They should clam down on corruption, then speak on how a person should live his or her life.
I won't be surprised that the very same people propagating the rules of Islam on others are themselves corrupted..
Quote
 
 
Friend of Dorothy
#8 Friend of Dorothy December 2011
What I see here is a large assumption that this young man is not repaying the loan. Who says? If you were to read a few other articles you would know that Petronas stopped "sponsoring" him in 2009, almost 2 years ago. Im thinking this might be around the time that his father reported him missing. Either way who is to say that he is not been repaying the loan since.
Quote
 
 
Colm
#7 Colm December 2011
It is not safe to assume that a homosexual is not religious, in the same way it is not safe to assume that relgious persons, even clerics, are without sexuality or even (God Forbid) homo-sexuality. There was once a witch hunt in Europe led by Christian religious zealots (the Inquisitions). We now know that they were evil, sick, demented perverts who loved torture, power, control and oppression and I am not talking about the so-called "witches" (women who sought freedom from male-rape and abuse. Power perversion is a common characteristic of all oligarchical faith systems; the divine and the good will always be subjected to the human inclination to judge and exact retribution where the ordinary man has no recourse against power elites. These elements pervade Islam (in the same way the once did Christianity) resulting in the oppression of masses of its poor, under educated, illiberated or deliberately stupid adherents (no one cares about the latter). Would Isalm not be better off, ridding itself of its oppressive instincts (which by default nurture extremism), than chasing poor, harmless, honourable, heroic men like Mr. Rosli around the planet. Frankly its pathetic. I pray every day for those followers of Mohammed, who read tolerance, wisdom and acceptance in his words instead of seeking to bash out the vitriol of oppression and judgment which he NEVER intended.
Quote
 
 
Colm
#6 Colm December 2011
It is not safe to assume that a homosexual is not religious, in the same way it is not safe to assume that relgious persons, even clerics, are without sexuality or even (God Forbid) homo-sexuality. There was once a witch hunt in Europe led by Christian religious zealots. We now know that they were evil, sick, demented perverts who loved torture, power, control and oppression and I am not talking about the so-called witches. Power perversion is a common characteristic of all oligarchical faith systems; the divine and the good wil always be subjceted to the human inclination to judge and exact retribution. These elements pervade Islam (in the same way the once did Christianity) resulting in the oppression of massess of its poor, under educated, illiberated or deliberately stupid adherents. Would Isdalm not be better off, ridding itself of its oppressive instincts (which by default nurture extremism), that chasing poor, harmless, honourable, heroic men like Mr. Rosli around the planet. Frankly pathetic. I pray evcery day for those followers of Muhommed, who read tolerance, wisdom and acceptance in his words instead of seeking to bash out the vitriol of oppression and judgment.
Quote
 
 
Ara
#5 Ara December 2011
"The best government could do is to get PETRONAS off his parents' back." WHAT THE HELL!!! Better from the start, he should sponsored by u.. rm890k is not small money to be forgotten.
Quote
 
 
Owenmatt
#4 Owenmatt December 2011
There are as many gay Muslims as there are gay Christians as there are gay Buddhists as there are gay Atheists. This is not a "Western Disease", it is simply a fact of human sexuality. It is not the result of "temptation" or choice. If you suspend your religious bias and rely on the best data and evidence science has to offer on the subject you would accept that.
It would make no difference if you spent 100 hours a week "educating" students about how to be a good and proper Muslim, there would still be the exact same number of homosexuals. The only thing you will achieve is creating a populace hostile to anyone who is even slightly different to your narrow interpretation of scripture, and ensuring that all gay men live their lives in secret shame.
The fact is that we cannot have a rational debate in Malaysia about anything that may challenge "what is written". Providing equal rights for gay men and women will never happen in this country because the debate on moral issues is mired in the 7th Century. We've learned so much since then that can better instruct us on issues such as this, to the betterment of all citizens.
Quote
 
 
Keris Emas
#3 Keris Emas December 2011
The New Malay Dilemma.... last time Sufiah now Ariff. All bright genius fall...brings down Islamic
Malay images. I cannot understand why must this fellow wear "baju melayu" for the ceremonies especially
if it "black" just like Our official palace or military code dress. He must seek sort of vengeance or to show to the
world he can do it. He must have a hidden agenda for it.
Quote
 
 
SDAR926
#2 SDAR926 December 2011
Let him pay the loan not his parents...pity them.
Quote